Fear or favor corrupts news
A compromising media precludes a free press
The First Amendment to the United States Constitution
provides that Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, of
prohibiting free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or the press; or
the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a
redress of grievances. That amendment, quoted above, is justly held to provide the
basis for Americas tradition of a free press.
In drafting the amendment, Americas founding fathers affirmed the fundamental right
of citizens to be informed about all sides of an issue without government interference.
Thomas Jefferson even went so far as to write: If it were left to me to decide
whether we should have a government without a free press or a freed press without a
government, I would refer the latter. And African-American News&Issues is in
complete accord with Jefferson, insofar as our publication exists for the sole purpose of
reporting all the news, without fear of favor from an uncompromising Black perspective.
Popular credos notwithstanding, the fact that we have been awarded two consecutive
Tell It Like It Is Awards from no less a watcher on the wall than Cleo Johnson
Mc Laughlin, the dynamic leader of Texas Black United Fund and we have received accolades
from a grateful public, e.g., Godfrey Eta, Harris County Sheriffs Departments
first native African detective and Jim Marshall, president of Afro-American Legal Defense
League, who will readily testify that we practice what we preach. And as a result, we have
become a forum of last resort for citizens whose issues are often ignored by the only
daily newspaper and system friendly mainstream media, in Americas fourth largest
city.
For that reason, AAN&I would be remiss to allow a publication that claims to be,
Houstons Leading Black Newspaper, to go unchallenged after refusing to
recognize the efforts of New Black Panther Partys Quanell X, because the publisher
deemed his actions inappropriate.
I went to the sister, thinking perhaps, I was unintentionally left out of an article
reporting our town hall meeting at S.H.A.P.E. Center, although I was the primary
facilitator, Quanell told AAN&I, the day (Oct. 4. 2002) following the
controversial meeting that called for a boycott of the Houston Chronicle. As it turned
out, Sonceria Messiah-Jiles, publisher of The Houston Defender, allegedly resented the
fact that Quanell had embarrassed HAULs president, Sylvia Brooks.
Brooks had seized an opportunity to berate AAN&I for a series of articles that we had
written about Texas Southern Universitys President Priscilla Slade, when Quanell
quickly stepped forward and condemned her for attacking a brother without first seeking
counsel with him. When Roy Douglas Malonson, who founded AAN&I in February 1996,
responded to Brooks criticism in an article (We stand accused!), in our
Oct. 16-22, 2002 edition, he concluded that the controversy started by Brooks was actually
a female thing, insofar as Houston has a coalition of Super
Sisters that have each others back.
While its commendable our Super Sisters have such a strong bond, personal positions
have no place in a free press that is obligated to report all news without fear or favor.
James Madison, another founding father reasoned: Knowledge will forever govern
ignorance, and a people who mean to be their own governors, must arm themselves with the
power that knowledge gives. A popular government without popular information or the means
of acquiring it is but a prologue to a farce or a travesty. Translation: When a free
press can be compromised by fear of losing advertising contracts, or the favor of
prestigious contacts, it leaves a powerless or disenfranchised citizen without a voice.
AAN&I can cite a litany of lonely battles weve been forced to fight, in this
one-daily newspaper metropolis (which in itself is a travesty), that was also completely
ignored by a system- friendly mainstream media, including most of Houstons leading
Black newspapers. We speak of the TAAS test scandal, that literally destroyed the life of
an educator who was doing nothing more than what Dr. Rod Paige had ordered her to do. In
hindsight, we well understand why Terry Abbot became HISDs media spin master, who
used his favor with the mainstream media to steer them away from the controversy that very
well could have kept President George W. Bush out of the White House.
We also challenged the ongoing racism in the Sheriffs Department long before other
media were forced to grudgingly report it and that it is business as usual in the Harris
County Commissioners Court, that should be kicking itself for dooming the Harris
County Hospital District to fail, when it forced Lois Moore out as CEO. Nevertheless, we
have no need to remind our readers how many articles we reported that other media flatly
refused to touch. Although there is no official oath journalists takes, there, indeed, is
a code that we are obligated to adhere to.
We at AAN&I simply cant afford the luxury or picking and choosing what we report
and still consider ourselves an objective, creditable free press. John Milton, in his
Areopagitica, written over 340 years ago, put it this way: Truth indeed came into
the world with her divine Master, and was a perfect shape most glorious to look on: but
when He ascended, and His apostles after Him were laid asleep, then straight arose a
wicked race of deceivers, who
took the virgin Truth, hewed her lovely form into a
thousand pieces, and scattered them to the four winds.
Apparently, Milton was preparing us for disenchantment with 2002 Americas media.
Indeed, today there are complaints from all segments of society about news media
incompetence, about over-hyping and trivializing the news, of strong and incessant
ideological bias in the reporting of the news and outright political propaganda being
packaged and disseminated as the bona fide news of the day (and week). The foregoing
addresses, The Oath They Never Took, a book of codes for journalist that
continues: The untenable track record, suggests that our news media needs a
Hippocratic Oath more than our doctors do.
Thus, the following is the outline of American Society of Newspaper Editors (founded in
1922) Canons of Journalism. I. Responsibility (of newspaper and journalist);
II, Freedom of Press (a vital right of mankind); III. Independence (fidelity
to the public interest); IV. Sincerity, Truthfulness, Accuracy (good faith with readers);
V. Impartiality (news reports free from opinions or bias) and VI. Fair Play, Decency
(recognition of private rights, prompt correction of errors). There is much more, but, in
essence, a creditable journalist is obligated to report all news without fear or favor.
|